A lender requires all applicants to have at least 3 traditional credit tradelines (credit cards, auto loans, mortgages). Applicants using only alternative credit (rent, utilities) are denied. Data shows this disproportionately affects immigrant and minority communities. What is this?

Question

Accepted Answer

Disparate impact — a facially neutral credit requirement with disproportionate effect on protected classes This is disparate impact. The 3-tradeline rule sounds objective and applies equally, but it disproportionately excludes groups who historically rely on alternative credit (recent immigrants, younger borrowers, certain minority communities). If the lender cannot demonstrate that this specific requirement is necessary for assessing creditworthiness AND that no less restrictive alternative exists (such as accepting alternative credit data), the policy violates fair lending laws. Many regulators now encourage acceptance of alternative credit precisely to address this type of impact.

A lender requires all applicants to have at least 3 traditional credit tradelines (credit cards, auto loans, mortgages). Applicants using only alternative credit (rent, utilities) are denied. Data shows this disproportionately affects immigrant and minority communities. What is this?

Drill 2,078 more questions like this, free

More Ethics practice questions

Free practice by category